InspiringClicks

Losing Traffic From AIO? Here’s The Silver Lining

Terms you need to know:

  • LLM (Large Language Model)
  • AIO (AI Overviews)
  • CTR (Click-through-rate)

AI Impact on SEO

 “Google AIO has transformed Google from a “search engine” into an “answer engine…”

Chegg on AI Impact on Search Traffic (2024)

Large Language Model (LLM) is programming in AI that allows it to use deep learning to generate text, and it’s now being used for AI overviews (AIO) — which usually appear high on search results. This has people asking, will AI overviews decrease websites traffic? Before worrying about AI impacting your SEO, there’s something you should remember:

A decrease in CTR (Click-through-rate) due to AI Overviews do not necessarily mean a loss of future value. It only signals a shift in user behavior from a “click-first” mentality to a “get the answer and move on” mentality.

The bottom line is that if someone needs the product or service you offer, they can’t exactly move on with just an answer. When was the last time an answer booked your hair appointment?

There are more than 8 billion Google searches for products or services alone. Google will always be a search engine because people are not always looking for answers, sometimes, they want solutions.

In this article, we’ve got both.

  • How does AI impact SEO?
  • Will AI overviews decrease my website traffic?
  • Can LLM affect my company’s ability to earn revenue online?

Keep reading to find out.

Do AI Overviews Reduce Website Traffic?

Data has shown that AI overviews can reduce Click-through-rates (CTR). Here is a comprehensive analysis of multiple independent research studies showing the impact of AI on website traffic.

Research Study CTR Impact Methodology & Sample Size Key Findings
Ahrefs Study
April 2025
-34.5%
Position 1 CTR reduction
300,000 keywords analyzed
• 150,000 keywords with/without AI Overview
• March 2024 vs March 2025 comparison
Position 1 CTR dropped from 0.073 to 0.026 for AI Overview keywords
99.2% of AI Overview triggers are informational queries
Siege Media Study
May 2025
-21.9%
Homepage CTR reduction
50 national websites
• 28 B2B and 22 B2C websites
• Last 3 months vs previous 3 months
Homepage clicks increased 10.7% but CTR decreased 21.9%
Homepage traffic converts 3-8% vs 1-4% sitewide
Amsive Analysis
2025
-15.49%
Average CTR drop
700,000 keywords
• 10 websites across 5 industries
• Before/after AI Overview rollout comparison
Up to -37.04% when combined with featured snippets
+18.68% CTR boost for branded results in AI Overviews
Mail Online Case Study
2025
-56%
CTR decrease
Publisher traffic analysis
• Top-ranking keywords analysis
• Before/after AI Overview comparison
Significant impact on news and publisher websites
Ahrefs Study
April 2025
CTR Impact
-34.5%
Position 1 CTR reduction
Methodology & Sample Size
300,000 keywords analyzed
• 150,000 keywords with/without AI Overview
• March 2024 vs March 2025 comparison
Key Findings
Position 1 CTR dropped from 0.073 to 0.026 for AI Overview keywords
99.2% of AI Overview triggers are informational queries
Siege Media Study
May 2025
CTR Impact
-21.9%
Homepage CTR reduction
Methodology & Sample Size
50 national websites
• 28 B2B and 22 B2C websites
• Last 3 months vs previous 3 months
Key Findings
Homepage clicks increased 10.7% but CTR decreased 21.9%
Homepage traffic converts 3-8% vs 1-4% sitewide
Amsive Analysis
2025
CTR Impact
-15.49%
Average CTR drop
Methodology & Sample Size
700,000 keywords
• 10 websites across 5 industries
• Before/after AI Overview rollout comparison
Key Findings
Up to -37.04% when combined with featured snippets
+18.68% CTR boost for branded results in AI Overviews
Mail Online Case Study
2025
CTR Impact
-56%
CTR decrease
Methodology & Sample Size
Publisher traffic analysis
• Top-ranking keywords analysis
• Before/after AI Overview comparison
Key Findings
Significant impact on news and publisher websites

Sources

Ahrefs Research: “AI Overviews Reduce Clicks by 34.5%” by Ryan Law and Xibeijia Guan, April 17, 2025
Siege Media: “Homepage Traffic is Up 10.7% from AI Overviews and LLMs [50-Site Study]” by Ross Hudgens, May 19, 2025
Search Engine Land: “New data: Google AI Overviews are hurting click-through rates” April 21, 2025
Search Engine Journal: “Pew Research Confirms Google AI Overviews Is Eroding Web Ecosystem” July 23, 2025

Should I Worry About AI in Search Hurting My Revenue?

You should not worry about AI overviews hurting your revenue if you take steps to increase your online visibility and optimize for SERP Answer Features. While AI Overviews provide quick answers to user questions, they rarely deliver complete solutions for products or services—and that’s where the real opportunity lies.

Most search queries are educational rather than commercial, which means AI Overviews can actually increase both clicks and revenue for businesses that secure visibility within them. This happens in two ways:

  1. Direct Citation Traffic: Users click on the citations within the overviews and land directly on your website, often with higher intent since they’ve already been pre-qualified by the AI summary.
  2. Brand Awareness Amplification: Even when users don’t click immediately, they become familiar with your business name, creating future branded search opportunities and direct navigation to your site.

AI Overviews Increase Brand Awareness Even If they Decrease Clicks

The brand awareness effect is particularly powerful. There have been documented cases where websites experienced decreased clicks to individual pages but saw significant increases in homepage traffic. This pattern reveals that while AI Overviews may reduce immediate click-through rates, they simultaneously boost brand recognition, leading to more branded searches and homepage visits over time.

This shift can actually improve revenue outcomes because AI tools work like word-of-mouth recommendations. When people see a brand mentioned by AI, some remember it and search for that company later when they’re actually ready to buy. These visitors already know the business is a credible option and come to the site with buying intent, not just browsing. This focused traffic converts better than people who stumble across random blog posts while doing general research

AI overview that features InspiringClicks in a citation
AI Impact on SEO for our Website

AI overviews have single-handedly boosted our brand awareness and exposure for searches we might have otherwise gone unnoticed for.

InspiringClicks appears in service-related AI overviews for SEO. If someone looking for SEO packages asks Google a question like “Are there companies in Calgary that offer SEM and SEO packages”, they are likely to find us on AIO. While that does not necessarily mean they are going to click on the citation leading to our page, it’s a win whether they do or not, because they will remember our name, InspiringClicks.

Want to Start Ranking on AI Overviews?

We get you found on featured snippets and AI overviews with SEO services that focus on driving more revenue for your business.

AI-era SEO? We’re Already There ✓

Answer Engine Optimization (AEO)

Get featured in AI Overviews and ChatGPT responses for maximum brand exposure

Featured Snippets Ranking

Achieve SERP answer features that help drive more qualified leads to your website

Human-Written Content Strategy

Recieve high-quality pages like this published on your website regularly

ROI-Driven Partnership

Get CRO (Conversion Rate Optimization) alongside SEO to help turn more clicks into paying customers or clients

Build Your Authority

We optimize your website to send strong E-E-A-T signals that help broaden search engine rankings

Local Market Expertise

Local digital marketing knowledge that gives you competitive advantages

The SEO of the Future is Here

No more worrying, no more guessing. SEO that actually works in the age of AI.

Ready to grow your business? Give us a call to discuss your SEO strategy.

Team of AI optimization experts  smiling at camera

Author

  • Adam Hamadiya

    Adam Hamadiya is a professional content writer, SEO expert, and serial entrepreneur. As co-founder of InspiringClicks, he develops SEO, SEM, and digital marketing strategies that deliver measurable growth for businesses worldwide.

,

Related Posts